My Criticism Of K.S Valdiya's Paper Published In Current Science
Summary:
and Valdiya's reply was not satisfactory at all..
To those unfamiliar with the sequence of events:
1) Giosan et al publish a paper in the May 2012 issue of PNAS on fluvial geomorphology of rivers around the Harappan civilization and conclude amongst other things that the Sutlej and Yamuna rivers got diverted from the channels now occupied by the river Ghaggar (Haryana Punjab plains) to their
Content analysis:
Geographic context:
Location | Country | Latitude | Longitude |
Ghagga | IN | 30.0288 | 76.1083 |
Haryana | IN | 29.2899 | 76.0369 |
Kansas | US | 38.4981 | -98.3202 |
Keywords:
channels, Criticism, Current Science, events, fluvial geomorphology, geology, Giosan, Harappan civilization, Haryana Punjab plains, issue, K.S Valdiya, PNAS, reply, river Ghaggar, sequence, Sutlej, things, Yamuna rivers